Skip to main content
1 / 38

4 Neely Street

Stone Mills, ON

Detached

Baths
2
Sq ft (approx.)
2000-2500
Lot
101.92 x 84.86 Feet
  • Finished basement
  • Central air
  • 32 days on site
$249,900

Welcome to a truly unique opportunity to own a piece of history in the vibrant heart of Tamworth. This exceptional all-brick church, steeped in character and charm, is ready to embark on a new journey with its future owners. Whether you envision running it in its continued use or transforming this magnificent space into your dream home, the possibilities are boundless. As you enter, be captivated by the breathtaking high ceilings that create an open and airy atmosphere, complemented by the mesmerizing stained glass windows that infuse the space with colorful, ethereal light. The expansive main floor offers a generous canvas for your imagination, providing ample room to bring any vision to life, from a unique residential haven to a thriving community hub. Descend to the finished lower level, where additional versatile space awaits your creative touch. Complete with a fully equipped kitchen and two half baths, this area offers incredible potential for further expansion, entertaining, or converting into a cozy retreat. Nestled in a prime location, this property is conveniently close to all amenities, offering easy access to local shops, restaurants, and schools. Embrace the tranquility of nearby Beaver Lake, perfect for leisurely swims and outdoor activities. This beautiful church is the perfect canvas for your dreams to become reality. Schedule a viewing today and imagine the future that awaits you in this lovely space. New Furnace Dec 2025

Virtual Tour

3D Tour
Powered by iGUIDE

Listing Details

Added to site
October 21, 2026

Price History

Listing history

Sign in to view

Property

Style
Bungalow-Raised
Construction
Brick
Roof
Metal
Foundation
Stone
Interior
None
Lot Size
101.92 x 84.86 Feet

Parking

Garage
None
Covered Spaces
0
Total Parking
0
Parking Features
Private

Utilities

Water
Drilled Well
Sewer
Holding Tank
Heat Source
Propane

Location & Legal

Cross Street
Bridge St W/ Neely St
Parcel Number
450540296
Possession
Immediate
Occupancy
Vacant

Schools

Elementary

  • Tamworth Elementary School0.5 km

    Public · Limestone DSB · 145 students

    Grade 3 reading: 74% met the provincial standard · Grade 6 math: 36% met the provincial standard

  • St Patrick Catholic School4.5 km

    Catholic · Algonquin and Lakeshore CDSB · 50 students

Straight-line distance. Nearby schools are not necessarily the assigned schools — confirm catchment with the school board. Scores are EQAO provincial test results for 2024-2025.

Community

Postal area K0K

Population
115,850
Private dwellings
53,153
Median age
50.8
Average household size
2.4
Median household income
$83,000

Source: Statistics Canada, 2021 Census of Population, catalogue 98-401-X2021013. Adapted from Statistics Canada. This does not constitute an endorsement by Statistics Canada of this product.

Local market

Residential Freehold in Stone Mills · last 12 months

Median sold price
$524,900
Homes sold
110
Median days on market
38
Sale-to-list price
95.7%

Based on 110 recorded sales of residential freehold properties in Stone Mills over the last 12 months.

Rooms

2-piece on Basement, 2-piece on Basement

Second

  • Other16'3" x 12'9"

Main

  • Foyer7'8" x 6'2"
  • Other12'9" x 8'4"
  • Other14'2" x 21'11"
  • Other
  • Other6'10" x 7'3"

Basement

  • Bathroom5'5" x 4'5"
  • Bathroom8'7" x 4'6"
  • Kitchen11'1" x 7'
  • Recreation
  • Utility Room11'9" x 7'

Listed by

MCCAFFREY REALTY INC., BROKERAGE

Walk Score

Walk Score is unavailable for this address right now.

What this home costs

Are you a Canadian citizen or permanent resident?
For this home
Buying with someone?

Based on $12,495 down (5%) · 25 yrs · 5.50% fixed, checking today’s rate · Canadian citizen or PR · just me · before other debts.

Down payment

Minimum $12,495 (5%). With 20% or more down, no mortgage insurance is needed.

Rate type

For example, a quote from your bank. Leave it empty to use 5.50%.

This listing shows a well or septic system. Lenders and insurers usually want a water test and a septic inspection; they are in the cash breakdown as an optional line.

Rate: checking today’s rate. Every figure is an estimate.

Investment Analysis

Investor terms: 20% minimum down; mortgage rates for rental properties are often higher, so these figures can differ on purpose from “What this home costs”. Rate: checking today’s rate.

No recent nearby lease data. Enter a rent to see the numbers.

Mortgage: $1,220/mo (20% down, 5.5%)

Taxes: $0/mo · Insurance: $62/mo

Estimates only. Consult a financial advisor.

R

Reita | Assistant

Online

Reita said:

Reita is an automated assistant, not a licensed real estate agent. I can help you explore neighbourhoods, understand the market, and find our free tools. What are you looking for?

Interested in this property?

By submitting this form you consent to REintel, operated by Direct Realty Ltd. (6992 Hwy 62, Belleville, ON K8N 0L7) contacting you to respond to your inquiry and send you relevant property listings, market updates, and real-estate information. You can withdraw your consent at any time using the unsubscribe link in every email, or by contacting us at the mailing address above.

Cookie Preferences