10 & 11 Methodist Island
Tay, ON
- 3 bed
- 1 bath
- approx. 700-1100 sqft
- Detached
- 454 days on market
This charming family cottage offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and classic cottage living just a 5-minute boat ride from Victoria Harbour with easy access to Foodland, the LCBO, and other amenities. Located on sought-after Methodist Island, this 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom retreat features a bright, open-concept layout with vaulted ceilings and a cozy loft overlooking the kitchen, dining area, and living room. A wood stove anchors the living space, creating the ideal atmosphere for relaxed evenings. Step outside onto the spacious front deck, perfect for dining al fresco or enjoying quiet mornings overlooking the yard. A fire pit invites late-night s'mores and stories under the stars, while a separate bunkie with its own screened porch and double bunk beds offers extra space for kids or guests. Boat-access only and surrounded by nature, this peaceful cottage is the quintessential Georgian Bay escape. Whether you're swimming off the dock, relaxing in the sun, or heading into town for supplies, this property delivers the best of both seclusion and convenience.
Listing Details
- Taxes (2024)
- $3,314
- Listed
- June 10, 2025
Price History
Listing history
Sign in to view
Property
- Style
- Bungalow-Raised
- Age
- 31-50
- Construction
- Wood
- Roof
- Metal
- Foundation
- Piers
- Interior
- Primary Bedroom - Main Floor
- Lot Size
- 200.6 x 144.42 Feet
Parking
- Garage
- None
- Covered Spaces
- 0
- Total Parking
- 0
Utilities
- Water
- Lake/River
- Sewer
- Septic
- Heat Source
- Wood
Location & Legal
- Cross Street
- Hwy 12 and William St.
- Zoning
- RS-4
- Parcel Number
- 584840286
- Possession
- Flexible
- Occupancy
- Owner
Included
- Inclusions
- Refrigerator, stove.
- Exclusions
- Personal items.
Waterfront
- Water Body
- Georgian Bay
- Shoreline
- Sandy, Deep, Natural
- Docking
- Private
Schools
Elementary
- Severn Shores Public School2.1 km
Public · Simcoe County DSB · 475 students
Grade 3 reading: 77% met the provincial standard · Grade 6 math: 26% met the provincial standard
Straight-line distance. Nearby schools are not necessarily the assigned schools — confirm catchment with the school board. Scores are EQAO provincial test results for 2024-2025.
Community
Postal area L0K
- Population
- 38,386
- Private dwellings
- 22,207
- Median age
- 50.8
- Average household size
- 2.4
- Median household income
- $88,000
Source: Statistics Canada, 2021 Census of Population, catalogue 98-401-X2021013. Adapted from Statistics Canada. This does not constitute an endorsement by Statistics Canada of this product.
Local market
Residential Freehold in Tay · last 12 months
- Median sold price
- $573,000
- Homes sold
- 171
- Median days on market
- 28
- Sale-to-list price
- 96.1%
Based on 171 recorded sales of residential freehold properties in Tay over the last 12 months.
Listed by
Sotheby's International Realty Canada
Walk Score
Walk Score is unavailable for this address right now.
Location
Street View
Mortgage Calculator
$125,000
Estimated Monthly Payment
$3,070
Land transfer tax
Ontario land transfer tax only. An estimate — not legal or financial advice. Municipal land transfer tax applies in Toronto and is not included.
Investment Analysis
No recent nearby lease data. Enter a rent to see the numbers.
Mortgage: $3,070/mo (20% down, 5.5%)
Taxes: $276/mo · Insurance: $156/mo
Estimates only. Consult a financial advisor.
Reita | Assistant
Online
Reita is an automated assistant, not a licensed real estate agent. This listing mentions A fire pit invites late-night s'mores and stories under the stars, while a separate bunkie with its own screened porch and double bunk beds offers extra space for kids or guests.. I can help you explore neighbourhoods, understand the market, and find our free tools. What are you looking for?