73 Fifth Avenue
St. Thomas, ON
- 4 bed
- 4 bath
- approx. 2500-3000 sqft
- Detached
Originally constructed in 1916 and thoughtfully transformed into a remarkable private residence, this one-of-a-kind church conversion offers nearly 3,800 square feet of finished living space while preserving the architectural character that makes it truly unforgettable. Approached through a timber-framed covered entrance, visitors are greeted by a dramatic two-storey stained glass window that hints at the extraordinary spaces beyond. The heart of the home is the breathtaking great hall, where soaring 18-foot ceilings create an extraordinary sense of space. The original sanctuary architecture remains a focal point, highlighted by a dramatic floor-to-ceiling gas fireplace and viewed from an expansive mezzanine overlooking the room below. An open-concept kitchen with sit-up bar flows naturally into the main living and dining areas, creating an ideal setting for entertaining or everyday living.The versatile layout includes multiple living spaces, dens, studios, and work-from-home options, offering flexibility for families, professionals, artists, or anyone seeking a home unlike any other. The fully finished lower level features oversized windows, a spacious primary retreat with walk-in closet and luxurious five-piece ensuite, a bonus room, recreation space, and additional bath.Extensively updated throughout, the property features modern electrical, plumbing, insulation, furnace, central air, shingles, and numerous mechanical improvements completed over recent years. Outside, private fenced outdoor living areas provide inviting spaces for relaxing and entertaining.Rarely does an opportunity arise to own a piece of local history that so successfully combines timeless architecture with modern comfort. This distinctive residence delivers character, scale, and presence that simply cannot be replicated. Heating bills are 134/mth and hydro & Water average 212 to 303 per month.
Virtual Tour
Virtual Tour Available
Listing Details
- Taxes (2025)
- $3,651
- Listed
- September 8, 2026
Price History
Listing history
Sign in to view
Property
- Style
- 2-Storey
- Age
- 100+
- Construction
- Brick
- Roof
- Fibreglass Shingle
- Foundation
- Unknown
- Interior
- Other
- Lot Size
- 60.08 x 120.79 Feet
Parking
- Garage
- None
- Covered Spaces
- 0
- Total Parking
- 2
Utilities
- Sewer
- Sewer
- Heat Source
- Gas
Location & Legal
- Cross Street
- Wellington
- Parcel Number
- 352190102
- Possession
- Other
- Occupancy
- Owner
Included
- Inclusions
- Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Stove, Window Coverings, Theatre screen
- Exclusions
- Arcade equipment not included.
Schools
Elementary
- Pierre Elliott Trudeau French Immersion Public School0.5 km
Public · Thames Valley DSB · 445 students
Grade 3 reading: 62% met the provincial standard · Grade 6 math: 66% met the provincial standard
- Forest Park Public School1.2 km
Public · Thames Valley DSB · 460 students
Grade 3 reading: 29% met the provincial standard · Grade 6 math: 39% met the provincial standard
- Elgin Court Public School1.3 km
Public · Thames Valley DSB · 315 students
Grade 3 reading: 56% met the provincial standard · Grade 6 math: 29% met the provincial standard
Secondary
- Central Elgin Collegiate Institute0.9 km
Public · Thames Valley DSB · 690 students
Grade 10 literacy: 79% met the provincial standard
- Arthur Voaden Secondary School1.1 km
Public · Thames Valley DSB · 355 students
Grade 10 literacy: 48% met the provincial standard
- Parkside Collegiate Institute1.8 km
Public · Thames Valley DSB · 1015 students
Grade 10 literacy: 82% met the provincial standard
Straight-line distance. Nearby schools are not necessarily the assigned schools — confirm catchment with the school board. Scores are EQAO provincial test results for 2024-2025.
Community
Postal area N5R
- Population
- 30,680
- Private dwellings
- 12,933
- Median age
- 44.8
- Average household size
- 2.4
- Median household income
- $80,000
Source: Statistics Canada, 2021 Census of Population, catalogue 98-401-X2021013. Adapted from Statistics Canada. This does not constitute an endorsement by Statistics Canada of this product.
Local market
Residential Freehold in St. Thomas · last 12 months
- Median sold price
- $535,000
- Homes sold
- 613
- Median days on market
- 28
- Sale-to-list price
- 97.7%
Based on 613 recorded sales of residential freehold properties in St. Thomas over the last 12 months.
Rooms
2-piece on Main, 3-piece on Second, 5-piece on Lower, 2-piece on Lower
Second
- Bedroom10'7" x 7'9"
- Bedroom 213'9" x 13'
- Den10'6" x 7'9"
- Other14'5" x 13'8"
Main
- Bedroom10'2" x 7'3"
- Den10'5" x 7'7"
- Dining Room14'2" x 12'10"
- Family Room31' x 26'
- Kitchen15'11" x 12'10"
- Living Room14'5" x 11'6"
Lower
- Bedroom 312' x 10'1"
- Game Room23'8" x 21'
- Laundry7'10" x 5'11"
- Primary Bedroom22'4" x 15'6"
Listed by
SUTTON GROUP PREFERRED REALTY INC.
Walk Score
Walk
Bike
Scores by Walk Score®
Location
Street View
Mortgage Calculator
$149,980
Estimated Monthly Payment
$3,684
Land transfer tax
Ontario land transfer tax only. An estimate — not legal or financial advice. Municipal land transfer tax applies in Toronto and is not included.
Investment Analysis
No recent nearby lease data. Enter a rent to see the numbers.
Mortgage: $3,684/mo (20% down, 5.5%)
Taxes: $304/mo · Insurance: $187/mo
Estimates only. Consult a financial advisor.
Reita | Assistant
Online
Reita is an automated assistant, not a licensed real estate agent. I can help you explore neighbourhoods, understand the market, and find our free tools. What are you looking for?